The venue is chosen by Major League Baseball and traditionally alternates between the two leagues every year. (This tradition will be broken in 2007, when San Francisco is revealed to be the host for the 2007 All-Star Game. Pittsburgh Pirates will host the 2006 event.) The "home team" is the league in which the host franchise plays its games. The two managers are traditionally the managers of the previous season's two World Series teams.
Baseball fans vote on the starting position players for the All-Star Game, with ballots distributed at baseball games before mid-season and, more recently, on the Internet. As of 2004, pitchers and back-up position players are elected by other players, with the teams' managers then deciding how to fill any empty slots which may result from injury or other inability to play. Each major league team is guaranteed to have at least one player selected to participate. Selected players have sometimes declined to take part in the game, citing health concerns or personal matters; as a matter of courtesy, other players have generally been selected to take their place.
| Year | Winner | Score |
Venue/Host team | MVP |
| 1933 | American | 4-2 |
Comiskey Park, Chicago White Sox | |
| 1934 | American | 9-7 |
Polo Grounds, New York Giants | |
| 1935 | American | 4-1 |
Municipal Stadium, Cleveland Indians | |
| 1936 | National | 4-3 |
Braves Field, Boston Braves | |
| 1937 | American | 8-3 |
Griffith Stadium, Washington Senators | |
| 1938 | National | 4-1 |
Crosley Field, Cincinnati Reds | |
| 1939 | American | 3-1 |
Yankee Stadium, New York Yankees | |
| 1940 | National | 4-0 |
Sportsman's Park, St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 1941 | American | 7-5 |
Briggs Stadium, Detroit Tigers | |
| 1942 | American | 3-1 |
Polo Grounds, New York Giants | |
| 1943 | American | 5-3 |
Shibe Park, Philadelphia Athletics | |
| 1944 | National | 7-1 |
Forbes Field, Pittsburgh Pirates | |
| 1945 | Not held. |
| 1946 | American | 12-0 |
Fenway Park, Boston Red Sox | |
| 1947 | American | 2-1 |
Wrigley Field, Chicago Cubs | |
| 1948 | American | 5-2 |
Sportsman's Park, St. Louis Browns | |
1949 | American | 11-7 |
Ebbets Field, Brooklyn Dodgers | |
| 1950 | National | 4-3 (14 innings) |
Comiskey Park, Chicago White Sox | |
| 1951 | National | 8-3 |
Briggs Stadium, Detroit Tigers | |
| 1952 | National | 3-2 (5 innings, rain) |
Shibe Park, Philadelphia Phillies | |
| 1953 | National | 5-1 |
Crosley Field, Cincinnati Reds | |
| 1954 | American | 11-9 |
Municipal Stadium, Cleveland Indians | |
| 1955 | National | 6-5 (12 innings) |
County Stadium, Milwaukee Braves | |
| 1956 | National | 7-3 |
Griffith Stadium, Washington Senators | |
|
| 1957 | American | 6-5 |
Sportsman's Park, St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 1958 | American | 4-3 |
Memorial Stadium, Baltimore Orioles | |
| 1959-a | National | 5-4 |
Forbes Field, Pittsburgh Pirates | |
| 1959-b | American | 5-3 |
Memorial Coliseum, Los Angeles Dodgers | |
|
| 1960-a | National | 5-3 |
Municipal Stadium, Kansas City Athletics | |
| 1960-b | National | 6-0 |
Yankee Stadium, New York Yankees | |
| 1961-a | National | 5-4 (10 innings) |
Candlestick Park, San Francisco Giants | |
| 1961-b | TIE | 1-1 (9 innings, rain) |
Fenway Park, Boston Red Sox | |
| 1962-a | National | 3-1 |
D.C. Stadium, Washington Senators | Maury Wills, LA (NL) |
| 1962-b | American | 9-4 |
Wrigley Field, Chicago Cubs | Leon Wagner, LA (AL) |
| 1963 | National | 5-3 |
Municipal Stadium, Cleveland Indians | Willie Mays, SF (NL) |
| 1964 | National | 7-4 |
Shea Stadium, New York Mets | Johnny Callison, PHI (NL) |
| 1965 | National | 6-5 |
Metropolitan Stadium, Minnesota Twins | Juan Marichal, SF (NL) |
| 1966 | National | 2-1 (10 innings) |
Busch Memorial Stadium, St. Louis Cardinals | Brooks Robinson, BAL (AL) |
| 1967 | National | 2-1 (15 innings) |
Anaheim Stadium, California Angels | Tony Perez, CIN (NL) |
| 1968 | National | 1-0 |
Astrodome, Houston Astros | Willie Mays, SF (NL) |
| 1969 | National | 9-3 |
Robert F. Kennedy Memorial Stadium, Washington Senators | Willie McCovey, SF (NL) |
| 1970 | National | 5-4 (12 innings) |
Riverfront Stadium, Cincinnati Reds | Carl Yastrzemski, BOS (AL) |
| 1971 | American | 6-4 |
Tiger Stadium, Detroit Tigers | Frank Robinson, BAL (AL) |
| 1972 | National | 4-3 (10 innings) |
Atlanta-Fulton County Stadium, Atlanta Braves | Joe Morgan, CIN (NL) |
| 1973 | National | 7-1 |
Royals Stadium, Kansas City Royals | Bobby Bonds, SF (NL) |
| 1974 | National | 7-2 |
Three Rivers Stadium, Pittsburgh Pirates | Steve Garvey, LA (NL) |
| 1975 | National | 6-3 |
County Stadium, Milwaukee Brewers | Jon Matlack, NYM (NL) Bill Madlock, CHC (NL) |
| 1976 | National | 7-1 |
Veterans Stadium, Philadelphia Phillies | George Foster, CIN (NL) |
| 1977 | National | 7-5 |
Yankee Stadium, New York Yankees | Don Sutton, LA (NL) |
| 1978 | National | 7-3 |
San Diego Stadium, San Diego Padres | Steve Garvey, LA (NL) |
| 1979 | National | 7-6 |
Kingdome, Seattle Mariners | Dave Parker, PIT (NL) |
| 1980 | National | 4-2 |
Dodger Stadium, Los Angeles Dodgers | Ken Griffey, Sr., CIN (NL) |
| 1981 | National | 5-4 |
Cleveland Stadium, Cleveland Indians | Gary Carter, MON (NL) |
| 1982 | National | 4-1 |
Olympic Stadium, Montreal Expos | Dave Concepcion, CIN (NL) |
| 1983 | American | 13-3 |
Comiskey Park, Chicago White Sox | Fred Lynn, CAL (AL) |
| 1984 | National | 3-1 |
Candlestick Park, San Francisco Giants | Gary Carter, MON (NL) |
| 1985 | National | 6-1 |
Hubert H. Humphrey Metrodome, Minnesota Twins | LaMarr Hoyt, SD (NL) |
| 1986 | American | 3-2 |
Astrodome, Houston Astros | Roger Clemens, BOS (AL) |
| 1987 | National | 2-0 (13 innings) |
Oakland-Alameda County Coliseum, Oakland Athletics | Tim Raines, MON (NL) |
| 1988 | American | 2-1 |
Riverfront Stadium, Cincinnati Reds | Terry Steinbach, OAK (AL) |
| 1989 | American | 5-3 |
Anaheim Stadium, California Angels | Bo Jackson, KC (AL) |
| 1990 | American | 2-0 |
Wrigley Field, Chicago Cubs | Julio Franco, TEX (AL) |
| 1991 | American | 4-2 |
SkyDome, Toronto Blue Jays | Cal Ripken, Jr., BAL (AL) |
| 1992 | American | 13-6 |
Jack Murphy Stadium, San Diego Padres | Ken Griffey Jr., SEA (AL) |
| 1993 | American | 9-3 |
Oriole Park at Camden Yards, Baltimore Orioles | Kirby Puckett, MIN (AL) |
| 1994 | National | 8-7 (10 innings) |
Three Rivers Stadium, Pittsburgh Pirates | Fred McGriff, ATL (NL) |
| 1995 | National | 3-2 |
The Ballpark in Arlington, Texas Rangers | Jeff Conine, FLA (NL) |
| 1996 | National | 6-0 |
Veterans Stadium, Philadelphia Phillies | Mike Piazza, LA (NL) |
| 1997 | American | 3-1 |
Jacobs Field, Cleveland Indians | Sandy Alomar, CLE (AL) |
| 1998 | American | 13-8 |
Coors Field, Colorado Rockies | Roberto Alomar, BAL (AL) |
| 1999 | American | 4-1 |
Fenway Park, Boston Red Sox | Pedro Martinez, BOS (AL) |
| 2000 | American | 6-3 |
Turner Field, Atlanta Braves | Derek Jeter, NYY (AL) |
| 2001 | American | 4-1 |
Safeco Field, Seattle Mariners | Cal Ripken, Jr., BAL (AL) |
| 2002 | TIE | 7-7 (11 innings) |
Miller Park, Milwaukee Brewers | None selected. |
| 2003 | American | 7-6 |
U.S. Cellular Field, Chicago White Sox | Garrett Anderson, ANA (AL) |
| 2004 | American | 9-4 |
Minute Maid Park, Houston Astros | Alfonso Soriano, TEX (AL) |